§ 312g para. 2 no. 3 BGB

§ 312g para. 2 no. 3 BGB – Exclusion of the right of withdrawal for hygiene products


Legal basis: When does the right of withdrawal not apply?


According to § 312g para. 2 no. 3 BGB there is no right of withdrawal for certain products:


“Contracts for the supply of sealed goods which are not suitable for return for reasons of health protection or hygiene, if their seal has been removed after delivery.”

(Source: BGB § 312g)


This also applies if a seal in the form of special packaging or wrapping is not explicitly marked as a “hygiene seal,” but is already provided by the closed product packaging. Please note that, in the broader sense, a seal is not limited to a specific tamper-evident strip or seal; it may also be provided by the manufacturer’s intact original packaging.

This regulation serves to protect consumers and ensures that products that cannot be resold for hygiene or health reasons may not be returned.


What does “seal” mean in the legal sense?


Case law confirms that a seal is not only an additional protective film but also includes tamper-proof packaging that clearly defines first use. What matters is that once opened, the product can no longer be hygienically resold.


Which packaging meets this requirement?


1. The product's original packaging


✔ Many of our products are supplied in sealed packaging that clearly defines first use.

✔ This packaging protects not only the product itself, but also its hygienic condition.

✔ Opening the packaging therefore constitutes removal of the seal and excludes the right of withdrawal.


2. Disposable packaging for hygiene accessories


✔ Masks, hoses and other hygiene products are supplied in sealed individual packaging. .

✔ This protective packaging prevents contamination and guarantees the hygienic condition of the goods.

✔ If the seal is removed or the packaging is opened, the product can no longer be returned for hygiene reasons.



 

Why does the right of withdrawal not apply?


Many of our products come into direct contact with the skin, breathing air or bodily fluids. Once the packaging has been opened:


🔹 Hygienic safety can no longer be guaranteed.

🔹 Proper disinfection is not possible.

🔹 The product is subject to the statutory exclusion from the right of withdrawal.


➡ Therefore, an opened product may not be returned.


Additional legal grounds confirming the exclusion of the right of withdrawal


1. Recital 47 of the EU Consumer Rights Directive (2011/83/EU)


The German regulation is based on the EU Consumer Rights Directive:


“The right of withdrawal should not apply to goods that cannot be placed back on the market for hygiene reasons.”


➡ Key argument:

An opened or used hygiene product cannot be hygienically resold and therefore falls under this provision.


2. Case law on “seals”


The European Court of Justice (ECJ) and German courts have confirmed that the original packaging qualifies as protective packaging :


📌 ECJ judgment C-681/17 (FlixBus voucher)

🔹 A seal does not necessarily have to be an additional film.

🔹 What matters is whether opening the product means it can no longer be used safely.


📌 Hamburg Regional Court, judgment of 13.10.2016 – 327 O 90/16

🔹 Returns of hygiene products are excluded once they have been opened.

🔹 Reprocessing or disinfection is not possible.


📌 Dieburg District Court, judgment of 25.07.2019 – 20 C 484/19

🔹 Products that may come into contact with bodily fluids are considered sealed even without additional protective film.


➡ Key argument:

A hygiene product that can no longer be used safely after opening is subject to the statutory exclusion of the right of withdrawal.

 


 

Conclusion


✅ The right of withdrawal is excluded pursuant to § 312g Abs. 2 Nr. 3 BGB.

✅ The EU Directive confirms the protection of hygiene products.

✅ Court rulings establish that the original packaging also qualifies as a seal.


❌ Returns of opened medical or hygiene products are excluded for health reasons.


These legal principles serve not only to provide clarity for consumers, but also to protect the health of all customers.

  • CONTACT

    31, Kiesselbachweg,
    22399 Hamburg

    service@careshoppro.eu

    Contact 
  • Returns

    You may only return new, unopened undamaged items to us within 14 days.

    Right of withdrawal 
  • Payment

    Advance payment, credit card, PayPal, instant bank transfer, payment by invoice (Klarna)

    Payment 
  • Shipping

    All masks and accessories will be delivered between 2–3 days. Some Bipap and CPAP machines will be delivered between 3 and 12 days.

    Shipping 
1 of 4

Settings and features

Where can I have the device settings adjusted if I order it online?

You can use the settings from your usual CPAP therapy on the DreamStation or Dream Station Go. The steps are clearly explained in the instructions for use.

Can you set the device yourself?

You can adjust the device yourself at any time. The individual operating steps can be found in the instructions for use. For further assistance, we recommend contacting your sleep clinic or doctor.

What is the Flex level setting?

This allows you to adjust the level of pressure relief you experience when exhaling during therapy. This feature can be activated or deactivated by your specialist retailer. If your specialist retailer activates the “Flex” feature, they will already set a level specific to you on the device. You can increase or decrease this setting to a value between 1 and 3. The “1” setting represents a low level of pressure relief, while higher numbers represent greater pressure relief.

What is the ramp function?

To help you adjust more comfortably to the inspiratory pressure of your sleep therapy, you can ask your specialist retailer to set a ramp. This means that you set a low starting pressure and a period of time during which the device increases the pressure from the ramp starting pressure to the therapy pressure setting over the specified duration.

Devices

What is sleep apnea?

Sleep apnea is a common sleep disorder characterized by repeated pauses in breathing during sleep.

 

These interruptions, also called apneas, are caused by the collapse of the upper airways, which prevents oxygen from reaching the lungs.

 

Apneas can significantly affect your energy levels and mental performance, as well as your long-term health. Therefore, do not ignore potentially dangerous symptoms such as snoring and excessive daytime sleepiness; consult a sleep specialist. Treatment can help you get the sleep you need to feel like yourself every day.

Which sleep mask is right for you?

An overview of sleep masks

Your mask has a major impact on the effectiveness of your therapy. It should meet your personal needs and cause no leaks or pressure marks on your face. Also talk to your doctor about your personal habits and needs to find out which model is right for you.

We offer masks from the DreamWear range, which enable a high degree of freedom of movement thanks to their innovative design and are available in the Philips online shop. In addition, you can obtain these and other Philips sleep therapy masks from a specialist retailer of your choice.

CPAP vs. BiPAP: what’s the difference?

Although CPAP and BiPAP are identical in terms of mask use, function, and the effect of opening the airways, the two ventilation methods also differ in some respects.

Perhaps the most important difference is air pressure. CPAP has only one air pressure setting, while BiPAP has two. This means that a CPAP device applies constant pressure to the airways, whereas a BiPAP mask delivers higher pressure when inhaling and lower pressure when exhaling. As a result, CPAP users have to exert more effort when exhaling than BiPAP users.

What is positional sleep apnea?

In classic sleep apnea, the airways are repeatedly blocked during sleep, leading to interruptions in breathing. Positional sleep apnea is a special form of this condition. In this case, the airways are blocked predominantly when lying on the back.

Sleep apnea affects sleep quality and can have a significant impact on overall performance and health. If you have sleep apnea and apnea events occur twice as often when lying on your back as when lying on your side, your sleep apnea is likely positional. Sleeping on your side can significantly reduce your symptoms.

Bipap or cpap?

BiPAP (bilevel positive airway pressure) is a form of ventilation that combines a ventilator with spontaneous breathing. With BiPAP ventilation, the patient can breathe spontaneously without interrupting the preset ventilation rate.

This is a form of ventilation used in intensive care that enables pressure-supported ventilation.

It is used when the patient needs ventilation but should still train their own spontaneous breathing. In obstructive lung diseases such as COPD or asthma, BiPAP ventilation can only be performed with special monitoring, as there is a risk of insufficient or excessive ventilation.

CPAP therapy: Help for obstructive sleep apnea

WithCPAP therapythis is a respiratory therapy that takes place during sleep. It is considered the standard treatment and is the most commonly used method for obstructive sleep apnea (OSA)

Masks

Why an oxygen mask?

An oxygen mask (English: oxygen mask) is a device that covers the face or the nose and mouth,to enable the inhalation of pure oxygen or a breathing gas mixture under challenging conditions, including reduced atmospheric pressure, a contaminated environment, or hypoxia.

When should CPAP masks be replaced?

Why and how often should I get a new CPAP mask cushion?

If any part of the system shows signs of wear (cracks, splits, discoloration, cushion damage, etc.), you should discard and replace the component in question.

If you wear a full-face mask and notice that the valve is damaged, warped, or torn, you should replace the elbow. The mask should no longer be worn if the valve is damaged, as it can no longer perform its safety function.

Since the replacement schedule for your mask is tailored specifically to you, we strongly recommend that you read the detailed information in the instructions for use for your mask.

In general, the following signs indicate that the mask or one of its components should be replaced:

You have to keep tightening the headgear,The mask no longer feels soft and springy but stiff,You feel that the treatment is no longer as effective as before,The mask cushion feels slippery even after cleaning,The mask cushion is no longer clear and transparent,The mask cushion and frame show signs of wear, stiffness, cracks, or breaks.